Continuing the story that began in A Place Called Winter, Harry Cane returns to post-war
England after decades away. His arrival unsettles the family he left behind, particularly his daughter. As past choices resurface, Harry’s presence shapes the next generation in unexpected ways. This is a deeply affecting exploration of estrangement, reckoning, home
and the complexities of family.
When Harry Cane returns home to England, having worked as a farmer in Canada for decades, he can’t believe how much things have changed after two world wars. His estranged daughter Betty feels obliged to offer him a home.
Harry’s presence has a profound impact on her family including on his granddaughter Pip, who finally reveals why she is such hard work. Can Harry find peace in his twilight years amid his relatives or is it too late?
Beautiful storytelling. Four stars.
Natasha Harding
With his arms-wide-open storytelling, Patrick Gale gathers us into the life of Harry Cane, a Canadian wheat farmer struggling with his emotional and physical landscape. After years of eking out a living on the prairies, Harry returns to England to reconnect with his spirited daughter Betty, who has yet to forgive his abandonment. Glorious, immersive, tender.
Kerry Fowler
Longing, sadness and love are the emotions that colour this quietly devastating novel. Harry Cane, whose story Gale unfurled so movingly in A Place Called Winter, leaves behind Canadian wheat fields and joins family in 1950s England. Weaving his story with theirs, Gale chronicles secrets, heartbreak and happiness, as Harry embraces his twilight years with a twinkle in his eye and discovers the true meaning of home.
Eithne Farry
Patrick Gale has long been one of the most reliably captivating, sympathetic storytellers, often weaving in his own experiences into his novels: he lives on a beef in farm at the rugged far west of Cornwall, a county that features regularly, and his grandfather and father were prison governors-Love Lane is the name of the street on which stands Wakefield prison in West Yorkshire.
The central character in this latest novel, Harry Cane, is Mr Gale’s great-grandfather, who mysteriously left England in disgrace at the turn of the 20th century to forge a bleak existence as one of the first colonisers of the Canadian prairies. This part of his story is told in the 2015 novel A Place Called Winter.
Love Lane is set in 1952, when Harry, who has been forced to sell his homestead, receives a invitation to visit from his daughter, Betty, whom he last saw as a baby and who is now married to a prison governor (as she was in real life). As Harry disembarks in Liver-pool, however, his family is disconcerted by this shabby, toothless old man, who is a far cry from the handsome, affluent figure of their last photographs and Betty realises that she may not be able to look after him as she had envi-saged. The sadness, at times heart-stopping, is, however, redeemed by Harry’s ability for empathy, especially with his troubled grand-daughters. As ever, Mr Gale’s sense of time, place and human frailty is impeccable and scorchingly humane.
Kate Green 1.4.26
Achingly tender, subtle … infused with love in all its messy forms.
Love Lane reintroduces Harry Cane, who has made a life for himself as a wheat farmer in Canada, but is forced to return to England once more. There, he is reunited with his long-lost daughter and an extended family who lovingly accept their so-called ‘Cowboy Grandpa’. The novel is told from a number of perspectives and seamlessly spans decades, thanks to Gale’s masterful storytelling. It is atmospheric and tender, while portraying the frequently complex dynamics of family. Gale is a fantastic scene-setter, whether it’s the desolate prairies of Saskatchewan or the inside of Walton Prison; you won’t be able to put it down.
Harry Cane returns in Love Lane, Patrick Gale’s period drama that simmers with secret sexuality
Love Lane is an absorbing novel exploring the meaning of home and family through the story of Harry Cane, an ageing farmer in Canada obliged to return to 1950s England to the daughter he abandoned decades earlier.
I particularly enjoyed the early part of the book, in which Harry is forced to sell up and sail home.
This story of his search for love and family has the feel of a small-scale epic and, as the narrative shifts to England, I settled into the book comfortably.
Through Harry’s returned-emigrant eyes we see how life in 1950s Liverpool has been transformed by two world wars. “Betty made an effort not to prattle as she drove him the short distance to Walton, but felt she must defend the city against dour first appearances, so told him about its wealth of Georgian houses and unfinished rival cathedrals.” Such moments subtly evoke the atmosphere of a city reshaped by conflict and rebuilding.
Patrick Gale is a highly regarded historical and contemporary fiction writer and first introduced readers to Harry in A Place Called Winter. Love Lane continues Harry’s story.
In his author’s note, Gale reveals that Harry is modelled on the life of his great-grandfather, a farmer in Saskatchewan. Drawing on family memories and letters, Gale builds a narrative with a strong sense of authenticity and intimacy.
These influences extend to stories of life as a prison governor – Gale’s father governed
Wandsworth – at a time when the death penalty was still in use and homosexuality was illegal.
Gale is a skilled writer with an excellent sense of pacing. His opening immediately hooked me:
“For many years, Harry Cane and Paul Slaymaker were able to live the life they did, not only through scrupulous discretion, but because they never gave what they had a name or even put it into words.”
After Harry’s arrival, the narrative is told in third-person perspectives from Harry’s daughter, Betty, her husband, Terry, Harry’s granddaughter, Pip, and Pip’s husband, Mike. The challenges they face reveal the losses and practical hardships of the post-war era, with a great deal of social history emerging.
Betty is full of doubt about seeing Harry again, yet feels compelled to take him in, prompting her own self-examination. At times, however, some emotional scenes feel a little underdeveloped.
Homosexuality is a recurring theme. Mike’s romance with a school friend recalls Brideshead Revisited. At one point, he even considers marrying his lover’s sister as cover, “as a means of somehow enabling it to continue, only he liked her far too much to practise such a deception on her and very much doubted she would have let herself be deceived”.
Occasionally the prose feels a little too well-mannered or clinical when handling such intense material, and some chapter endings leave storylines hanging as the perspective shifts to another character. Yet Gale also offers quietly sharp observations, as when Harry remarks:
“People without secrets… are like people with very tidy houses: usually not worth knowing.”
The book’s greatest triumph is Harry – his gentle dignity and stoic acceptance of life’s
compromises. Love Lane is an involving story of reconciliation, secrets and compromise, rich in historical detail.
Hilary Fennell 25.3.26
Towards the end of Love Lane, elderly protagonist Harry Cane becomes a figure of twinkly-eyed mischief. Gossiping with his granddaughter Pip, he advises her that “people without secrets … are like people with very tidy houses: usually not worth knowing”.
Dangerously buried secrets are very much the order of the day in Patrick Gale’s 18th novel. We start as we mean to go on: Love Lane opens with a recounting of the clandestine relationship between widower Harry and his bachelor brother-in-law Paul Slaymaker, Englishmen who separately emigrated to Canada around the turn of the last century. We first meet them as homesteaders in the unforgiving Saskatchewan wilds; Gale aficionados who encountered Cane in 2015’s A Place Called Winter remember the dark cloud of scandal that hastened his departure from Britain. The “steady tenderness” between Harry and Paul, which is passingly reminiscent of Annie Proulx’s Brokeback Mountain, gives the men succour as their neighbouring farms weather the bitter economic vicissitudes of the 1920s and 30s, but their wordlessly powerful bond is for ever altered by the arrival of Dimpy, a woman down on her luck, and her hard-hearted son, Davy.
Delivered in a voice that’s often quite loudly expositional, the narrative sprints through the second world war. A series of events, many devastating and brutal, soon see Harry reconnecting with Betty, his long-lost daughter from an early marriage. The groundwork is laid for Harry’s somewhat equivocal return home. Whether those green and pleasant lands still constitute home for Harry after such a marked hiatus becomes one of the novel’s central questions.
After crossing the Atlantic, we’re introduced to a host of other narrative perspectives: affable Betty gets a good few chapters, as does her doughty husband, Terry, a prison governor. We also hear from their grownup daughter Pip and her ascetic husband Mike, both of whom have secrets of their own. These glimpses into lives adjacent to Harry’s as he returns to his radically changed birthplace round out Gale’s presentation of 1950s England. While he asserts that this is “a novel not a memoir”, it draws significantly on his family history and letters and is rich in rigorously detailed period colour. The realities of rationing, irascible charladies, clouds of Dubonnet and Ascot water heaters all feature in a colourful evocation of the times.
In Love Lane, it’s the alleyways and sidestreets of the narrative that provide most interest and entertainment. Secondary characters and subplots rather steal the show: the “galére of formidable, big-bosomed aunts” who raise Betty after her father absconds to Canada and her mother tragically dies provide a fabulously catty element. Whistle, Betty’s highly strung, free-speaking youngest daughter, is a breath of fresh air, as is racy Vivvy, who leads sensible ingenue Pip astray during her long engagement to Mike. But it’s an odd feature of the novel that the liveliness and appealingly gossipy tone of these peripheral sections often meant I lost sense of where the centre of the novel truly was. Harry becomes out of focus as all these other stories crowd in. When he very decisively takes centre stage again as the novel draws to a close, I was unsure how emotionally satisfying and successfully realised I found his arc.
Still, there is an enviable lightness to Gale’s sentences. The comedy has a Forsterian ease in its profound Englishness: asides about wedding day wardrobe malfunctions and bourgeois euphemisms for genitalia are all part of the novel’s unashamed Call the Midwife chumminess. Equally, Gale’s descriptions of the small commonplaces of domestic life often have a pure brilliance to them. A sketch of Mike’s nervous hands snapping the stems of sherry glasses and Harry’s great-granddaughter’s fascination with a long spiral of apple peel are particularly fine. There is darkness, too, especially with regards to the portrayal of the prison Terry governs. The criminalisation of queerness and Terry’s overseeing the hanging of two young and likely innocent inmates are attended to with dignity and nuance.
The novel’s title alludes, specifically, to the street on which Pip and Mike live in Wakefield, and where they host Harry – “Cowboy Grandpa” – for a few eventful weeks. But its significance extends beyond that. What is most palpable about this novel is the evident love the author feels towards the characters of his semi-fictional universe. There is a refreshing warmth and gentleness in Gale’s precisely imagined vision of these connected lives that makes for a kindly, immensely companionable read.
Michael Donkor 27.3.26
This isn’t a sequel to Gale’s Costa-shortlisted A Place Called Winter, but it does begin with that book’s protagonist.
Harry Cane has built a life as a farmer on the vast Canadian plains, and even found comfort in the arms of his brother-in-law (it was a scandal that forced Harry from Edwardian England in the first place). But times are changing, Harry is ageing, and a letter from Betty, the daughter he left behind, is the catalyst for a journey back to 1950s Liverpool.
Harry’s visit is largely a framing device, a pretext for a gentle, absorbing unfolding of the experiences and mores of new generations: housewife Betty; her prisoner governor husband Terry; and her two daughters, lively Pip and highly-strung Whistle.
Drawing substantially on Gale’s own family history, this empathic novel has the texture of social history: expect quiet surprises over sudden twists, and a satisfying, moving conclusion.
Stephanie Cross 27.3.26
